In the booming world of fresh dog food delivery, NomNom and Ollie consistently rank among the most trusted brands. Both promise high-quality, human-grade meals delivered to your doorstep, and both aim to revolutionize how we feed our dogs. But if you had to choose one, which is the better fit for your pup’s needs?
This comprehensive comparison covers their mission, ingredients, recipes, pricing, and customer satisfaction to help you make the best decision for your dog. For a more detailed look into NomNom specifically, continue reading to discover how it compares in terms of personalization, ingredient quality, and overall value.
Company Overview
NomNom
Founded in 2015 in Nashville, Tennessee, NomNom was created by a team of pet-loving scientists and veterinary nutritionists who believed in one thing: better dog health starts with better food. Their goal is to deliver personalized, pre-portioned meals based on your dog’s age, weight, activity level, and health conditions. Transparency, innovation, and science drive everything they do.
Ollie
Launched in 2016, Ollie emerged from the idea that traditional kibble wasn’t cutting it. This New York-based company was built on a foundation of love for dogs and a passion for high-quality, nutrient-rich meals. With human-grade food, customized meal plans, and a fun brand voice, Ollie has quickly carved out a loyal following.
Key Features and Benefits
NomNom
- Personalized meal plans based on health data
- Pre-portioned servings for convenience
- In-house veterinary nutritionist oversight
- Offers microbiome testing and health supplements
- Transparent ingredient sourcing
Ollie
- Human-grade ingredients
- Customizable feeding plans based on a short quiz
- Vet-formulated meals for all life stages
- Eco-friendly packaging
- Includes both fresh and baked food options
Both brands emphasize personalization, but NomNom’s edge lies in its data-driven health approach and added services like gut microbiome testing and real-time nutritional feedback.
Quality of Ingredients
NomNom uses restaurant-quality meats (like chicken, beef, turkey, and pork) paired with whole vegetables such as squash, spinach, and carrots. Their meals are gently cooked to preserve nutrients and avoid contamination, then tested in their labs to ensure balanced nutrient profiles.
Ollie also uses USDA-certified meats and fresh vegetables, all cooked in U.S.-based kitchens that meet the same standards as human food facilities. Their recipes avoid fillers, by-products, and artificial preservatives.
Both are outstanding in terms of ingredient quality. However, NomNom’s focus on food safety testing and transparent nutrient data may appeal more to pet parents managing specific health issues. For an in-depth analysis, check out this complete NomNom review that breaks down everything from ingredient sourcing to health testing services.
Unique Recipes
NomNom Recipes:
- Chicken Cuisine
- Beef Mash
- Pork Potluck
- Turkey Fare
Each recipe is formulated by board-certified veterinary nutritionists and features a consistent blend of protein, fiber, and fat. NomNom’s meals are ideal for dogs with sensitive stomachs or specific dietary restrictions.
Ollie Recipes:
- Beef with Sweet Potatoes
- Chicken with Carrots and Peas
- Lamb with Cranberries and Butternut Squash
- Turkey with Blueberries and Kale
Ollie emphasizes a flavorful profile with bold, dog-friendly ingredients. They also offer baked food in addition to fresh, giving pet owners more variety and storage flexibility.
Ollie wins on variety and novelty, while NomNom holds strong in targeted, health-forward formulation.
Pricing
NomNom pricing starts at around $3 per day for small dogs and scales with weight and caloric needs. Their flexible plans include optional add-ons like gut health kits and probiotic chews.
Ollie starts slightly lower, around $2 per day for small breeds. Like NomNom, they tailor plans to your dog’s size, age, and activity level. Ollie offers a half-box subscription for pet parents on a budget.
Both companies offer trial discounts, but NomNom’s extras (like lab-tested gut health services) make its pricing structure feel more premium—and potentially more beneficial in the long run.
Delivery and Convenience
Both brands offer free shipping across the continental U.S. and deliver food on a flexible subscription model. Meals arrive frozen or chilled and are ready to store in your fridge or freezer.
NomNom sends individually pre-portioned daily packs that make feeding as simple as tear-and-serve. Their customer portal allows you to update delivery dates, pause plans, and modify meals with ease.
Ollie ships in trays rather than daily packs. While they’re easy to scoop and serve, they can require a bit more handling and measuring compared to NomNom’s grab-and-go format.
NomNom’s packaging and user-friendly interface make it a more convenient option, especially for busy owners or multi-dog households. Their ability to pair food with data and testing services adds even more value. Want to know why so many pet parents are switching to NomNom? Explore the full scoop in this detailed NomNom review, filled with practical insights on how their system elevates your dog’s health journey.
Reviews
NomNom
NomNom receives consistently glowing reviews for improving digestion, coat quality, and overall vitality in dogs. Many pet parents report noticeable improvements in stool consistency, reduced allergy symptoms, and increased energy levels within just a few weeks of switching to NomNom. The meals’ balanced nutrition and portion control are frequently praised for helping dogs maintain a healthy weight.
Another standout point in NomNom’s reviews is the customer experience. Users commend the brand for its responsive and knowledgeable support team, who assist with everything from recipe adjustments to subscription management. Reviews also highlight the added value of NomNom’s optional health testing services, especially for dogs with chronic conditions or sensitive stomachs. This scientific, personalized approach earns consistent praise from veterinarians and pet owners alike.
Ollie
Ollie customers are generally very happy with their dogs’ enthusiasm for the food. The meals’ appealing aroma and texture often win over picky eaters, and many owners say mealtime has become a more enjoyable experience. Users also appreciate the variety of recipe choices and the availability of both fresh and baked food formats.
However, some reviews note that the trays can be messy and inconvenient, especially when portioning meals for multiple pets or storing leftovers. A few users have expressed a desire for more detailed nutritional information and wellness support services similar to what NomNom provides. That said, Ollie earns high marks for overall food quality, presentation, and subscription flexibility.
Both brands enjoy strong reputations for customer satisfaction. While Ollie wins points for its variety and flavor appeal, NomNom’s edge in science-backed nutrition, health tracking, and premium service gives it a distinct advantage for pet parents looking for more than just a meal.
Pros and Cons
NomNom
Pros:
- Board-certified veterinary nutritionist on staff: NomNom’s meals are formulated under the direct supervision of a veterinary nutrition expert, ensuring that your dog receives scientifically balanced nutrition for optimal health.
- Gut health testing and supplemental offerings: Pet parents can access additional wellness tools like microbiome testing kits and probiotic supplements. These services allow for a more personalized, diagnostic approach to pet nutrition.
- Pre-portioned daily meals: NomNom delivers meals in individually packaged servings tailored to your dog’s caloric needs. This eliminates guesswork and reduces waste.
- Exceptional transparency and lab testing: Ingredient sourcing is fully traceable, and each meal undergoes thorough testing for nutrient accuracy and safety. This is ideal for dogs with specific dietary requirements or sensitivities.
- Streamlined online management: Their digital portal allows users to make real-time adjustments to recipes, portion sizes, and delivery schedules with ease.
Cons:
- Slightly more expensive: NomNom is positioned as a premium service, and its advanced offerings come with a higher price point, which may be a barrier for some dog owners.
- Limited to fresh food (no baked options): Unlike Ollie, NomNom does not currently offer baked food alternatives, which might limit flexibility for some households seeking variety or shelf-stable options.
Ollie
Pros:
- Unique ingredient pairings with bold flavors: Ollie’s recipes feature creative ingredient combinations, such as lamb with cranberries or turkey with blueberries, that appeal to dogs with adventurous appetites.
- Fresh and baked options are available: In addition to fresh food, Ollie offers baked meals, giving pet owners greater flexibility in feeding and storage preferences.
- Slightly lower starting price: For pet owners new to fresh food or working within a budget, Ollie’s entry-level pricing is more accessible.
- Flexible subscription sizes (full or half box): Ollie allows customers to choose how much food they receive, which is useful for supplementing a dog’s existing diet or easing into fresh food gradually.
- Attractive packaging and branding: The Ollie experience includes playful branding and vibrant packaging that enhances the unboxing experience.
Cons:
- Trays can be less convenient than portioned packs: Meals arrive in multi-serve trays that require measuring, which can be less efficient than NomNom’s single-serve packs.
- No microbiome or lab-based health services: While Ollie’s meals are formulated with veterinary input, they do not offer the same level of ongoing nutritional diagnostics or wellness tracking that NomNom does.
Final Verdict
If you’re looking for bold, flavorful meals with a touch of variety, Ollie might be the way to go. Their flexible box sizes and inclusion of baked food make them a solid option for everyday feeding.
However, for pet parents who want a scientifically grounded, health-focused feeding plan with ongoing nutritional tracking and convenient packaging, NomNom stands above the rest.
To dive deeper into why NomNom continues to impress both dogs and their owners, review the comprehensive details shared earlier in this comparison.
Meet Sofi Dzneladze, a seasoned professional with over 10 years of experience dedicated to the well-being and care of our furry companions. Sofi’s expertise spans dog grooming, training, and behavior management, making her a trusted authority in the field of canine care. Sofi began her journey with a passion for understanding dogs on a deeper level: their appearance, behavior, needs, and unique personalities.
